December 11, 2025 Executive Compensation Executive & Director Pay Design Articles

Resource Library / Insights / Articles
Executive & Director Pay Design

Five Outside-the-Box Compensation Strategies for 2026 Permission to Experiment

Compensation committees entering 2026 face a new kind of uncertainty—one that feels less like normal economic cycles and more like whiplash.

It’s not just the now-familiar unpredictability of inflation or shifting consumer behavior; it’s the jolt of waking up to a policy reversal announced on social media before markets open, or trade rules rewritten overnight. The speed and intensity of these shocks make it difficult for compensation committees to anchor to long-term targets or assume stability from week to week. For many boards, setting incentive goals now feels less like the result of disciplined planning and more like building a castle on shifting sands.

For companies in stable industries, with predictable fundamentals, conventional approaches may still work well. But for organizations navigating structural transformation, extended investment horizons, or environments where external shocks loom large, something might have to give.

At the same time, the governance landscape is evolving. Institutional investors are fragmenting their voting blocs, and proxy advisors are signaling more flexibility around new approaches to incentive plans, such as long-dated grants and alternative goal frameworks. While boards have long adapted compensation design to fit strategy, investors and proxy advisors now appear more open to engaging in thoughtful experimentation and new ideas than in years prior.

Five Creative Approaches for Incentive Plans in 2026

What follows are five compensation approaches designed to meet the current moment. Each offers a potential path forward when traditional metrics become challenging or when the economic landscape keeps getting redrawn. For some companies, investors’ long-preferred three-year PSU cycles with predetermined metrics will remain relevant and, in many cases, preferred. But boards with conviction can always adjust compensation designs to business reality, even if they fly in the face of governance orthodoxy.

Boards that are willing to take measured risks and can explain their reasoning clearly may find these designs more compelling than sticking with frameworks built for stability in an unstable world. Considering these approaches isn’t “defensive;” it’s a chance to seize the moment and unlock agility and opportunity while competitors remain stuck in stasis.

ApproachDetails
Brutal SimplificationThrow out the scorecards and the weighted metrics. Pick the one or two things that matter most right now that you can measure. Maybe it’s maintaining gross margin in the face of rising input costs. Maybe it’s the ramp-up speed of domestic manufacturing. Whatever it is, make it crystal clear and put serious money behind it.

Why it works: In chaos, focus wins. Leaders know exactly what matters.

Why it doesn’t: Focus is powerful—but risky, and you could lock onto the wrong target, oversteer, or incentivize behavior that solves one problem while quietly creating three more.

Best for: Turnarounds or existential pivots requiring extreme focus.
The Five to Seven-Year BetCancel next year’s standard equity grant cycle. Instead, make a single, multi-year grant that vests based on where the company stands in 2030 or 2032. No annual refreshes, no short-term metrics. Just one big bet on long-term value creation.

Why it works: It aligns everyone with the timeframe needed to navigate structural economic change and frees executives from quarterly optimization games.

Why it doesn’t: Not every executive wants to wait that long to get paid—or stay that long. You’ll need clear exit ramps and fairness mechanisms for those who leave early without undermining the long-term nature of the plan, and clear rules for new entrants mid-cycle.

Best for: Multi-year transformations (digital, operational, or structural shifts).
The Horse Race If you can’t tell what “good” looks like in absolute terms, measure relative position. Rank your company against a carefully selected peer set or the broad economy—”the market”—and pay only for outperformance. This isn’t just about stock price; it can include market share gains, margin protection, or other competitive metrics. You could even combine absolute and relative performance: “We did well, and we won.” This is a viable option for many companies and won’t challenge traditional compensation orthodoxy as directly as the first two.

Why it works: In a storm, you can’t control the waves, but you can reward the captain who navigates them better than others.

Why it doesn’t: Relative metrics sound simple, but they rarely are. rTSR can be gamed by timing, and most “relative” measures aren’t tracked consistently or cleanly enough to withstand scrutiny. Setting the right performance period is crucial to help measure whether the strategy was successful.

Best for: Industries facing broad disruption or cyclical conditions.
The Conscious PlaceholderAdmit you don’t have the answers yet. Implement a one-year fully discretionary program with transparent guardrails. Tell executives, “We don’t know exactly what success looks like, but we’ll recognize it when we see it.” Then, document your reasoning meticulously. Apply that discretion in the bonus and give everyone a modest RSU grant to totally get out of the goal-setting business.

Why it works: Sometimes, the only way to honestly review performance is in hindsight. At the end of the day, honesty is often the only credible position. 

Why it doesn’t: Kicking the can only works if the road gets smoother. Next year might bring even more uncertainty—and you could be stuck having the same conversation all over again. There may be high pressure to rationalize away poor performance for the sake of ensuring payouts or forgive mediocrity due to “uncontrollable factors” that are, ultimately, business realities.

Best for: High-trust environments and companies navigating major transition years.
Business as Usual, with ConsequencesKeep your existing program but accept the tradeoffs: you might end up with outcomes that don’t align with your actual assessment of performance. Goals may need to be set so widely that they lose meaning, and you may spend the year-end in complex adjustment debates. If the payouts end up feeling right, accept that you may have just gotten lucky, but understand that over time, the payouts will likely level out to be fair—some good years, some bad. Over time, employees will hopefully learn to trust that “one bad year” isn’t permanent.

Why it works: It doesn’t always work—at least not perfectly—but it’s the path of least resistance for governance-constrained boards. It keeps leaders focused on running the business instead of redesigning compensation plans.

Why it doesn’t: Fixed targets can limit agility. In uncertain times, they can box executives into playing it safe or spark distracting debates about adjustments in environments with low trust between the board and management.

Best for: Moderate volatility or industries with predictable fundamentals.

It is important to note that the designs above, by dint of their outside-the-box nature, may not be initially embraced by investors. But companies that ground any changes in strong, company-specific rationale, and communicate that rationale with conviction and persistence, can successfully move outside of orthodoxy. Recent history is filled with examples of companies that pioneered new incentive designs that, despite a few years of low Say-On-Pay recommendations, eventually proved to be successful. Continued, intentional shareholder outreach is key, from the moment plans are presented through demonstrating why the designs work to benefit all stakeholders long-term.

Beyond Compensation Theater

Stock price remains the ultimate scorecard—eventually. It can be rigged short-term, it can be risky, and it doesn’t always tell the whole truth. But over sufficient time, it should capture an accurate reflection of business health and performance. However, in periods of structural economic change, the gap between company actions and market verdict can widen considerably.

The awkward truth about executive compensation is that many companies have been trapped in a ritualistic annual exercise—setting reasonable targets, making predictable adjustments, and managing the process while dutifully checking governance boxes along the way. But today, those same governance checkboxes might push companies toward approaches that won’t drive performance in all situations. Perhaps, disruption also brings opportunity: permission to step outside orthodoxy, to embrace simpler, longer-term measures, and to preserve the flexibility boards need to stay agile as conditions change.

Uncertainty doesn’t seem to be going away. The question is whether boards will adapt to this moment of instability—exploring compensation approaches that flex with the business through pivots. With the governance landscape shifting and institutional investors showing more openness to a wider range of approaches, boards have an opportunity to be bold, experiment, and explain why their programs match today’s reality. As committees enter 2026 design discussions, consider questions like these—not just about mechanics, but about meaning:

  • Are we clear on what “performance” really means in our unique context??
  • Do our programs reward adaptability and sound judgment, or only precision against pre-set plans?
  • Where do we need measurement, and where do we need discretion and trust?
  • When we say “pay for performance,” can we define what performance means—and would our stakeholders agree?

Boards that can answer those questions honestly won’t just manage through volatility; they may redefine what credibility looks like in executive pay and give themselves space to seize opportunities ahead. The question isn’t just how to pay executives fairly during upheaval—it’s whether this moment invites boards to build something new around compensation, something that acknowledges the reality of our uncertain times rather than pretending we can predict what’s coming next.


View the full article as it was originally published.

Margaret Hylas

View original article

Related Insights